Marshal Luke Davis has three mail-order brides competing to win his hand. Is any one of them right for him? Boardinghouse owner Rachel Hamilton doesn’t have the courage to tell Luke she loves him. Can she swallow her pride and help him choose his mate? Will Luke discover true love through a contest of the heart?

The Corbett brothers begin hosting socials for singles in Lookout, Texas, after they royally messed up a matchmaking scheme against their cousin. Shannon and Leah are the mail-order brides stranded in town without husbands. Will they each choose to marry for security, or can they hold out for true love?

Reporter Jacqueline Davis is suspicious of the new preacher. But will a budding romance overshadow her determination to uncover his secrets? Jailbird Carly Payton is looking for a new start in life. Garrett Corbett is looking to avoid marriage with a jailbird. Will love blossom with a second look?